My wife and I discovered Wagster at a local event and out of all the dog treats there, Duke and Nove loved these the most. We purchased six packs of apple & peanut butter and the peanut butter & molasses flavors, and we definitely support their cause. They smell great even to use. Sometimes we use them as a stand-alone treat, but our dogs are picky eaters and won't eat their dog food even with various flavored broth toppers, so we tried crumbling this on top, and they devour their food now. It is easy to crumble to a fine blend and sprinkle on top.